Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Exploit Case
Regulation

Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Exploit Case

November 18, 20262 min read

U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke in Manhattan has acquitted brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, who were accused of taking $25 million from trading bots on Ethereum. The ruling closes the criminal case without a retrial. The court called the prosecution the first of its kind.

What the judge decided

Clarke granted the brothers' motion for a judgment of acquittal on Monday, November 16. She cleared them of all three counts: wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. According to Decrypt, prosecutors failed to show that the brothers made a material misrepresentation, and without that there is no wire fraud conviction.

The money laundering count rested on the proceeds of the alleged fraud, so it fell along with it. In November 2025 the first trial ended without a verdict. Jurors could not agree, and the court declared a mistrial. Now the judge has settled the question herself. There will be no new jury.

How the brothers acted in April 2023

The targets were sandwich bots. These are automated traders that earn from MEV (maximal extractable value): they spot someone else's trade in the queue, buy the asset ahead of it and sell right after, pocketing the price difference. Such bots operate, for example, on decentralized exchanges like Uniswap.

According to the court's description, the brothers worked in several steps:

  • they placed bait transactions aimed at specific bots
  • they exploited a bug in a relay's code and saw the bots' bundled trades before they were committed to a block
  • they swapped the bait transactions for trades that sold the tokens
  • they left the bots with roughly $25 million in losses in about 12 seconds

Authorities arrested the brothers in May 2024. Prosecutors said they spent months planning the attack and took steps to hide the proceeds. At last year's trial an insider testified that the pair had planned the scheme in advance, and the defense had earlier tried to block evidence of their Google searches.

The court held that even conduct that may have frustrated the spirit of MEV-Boost does not by itself make someone a fraudster.

Why the prosecution fell short

To convict for wire fraud, prosecutors had to prove a material misrepresentation. In Clarke's finding, none of the government's theories did that. The judge stressed that she was weighing not whether the brothers' conduct was right or moral, nor even whether it broke laws they were never charged under.

"A trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use."

- Jessica Clarke, U.S. federal judge, on Ethereum, from the ruling acquitting the Peraire-Bueno brothers

Clarke accepted that the scheme may have frustrated the spirit of MEV-Boost. That software lets Ethereum validators hand the ordering of transactions to specialized block builders. It is not enough for a conviction. In a footnote the judge added that the prosecution raises serious due process concerns, though she declined to rule on that question.

A case the industry watched

The crypto market followed the trial closely. In her ruling Clarke called the case a first of its kind, the same label the government used in its indictment. By the logic of the ruling, a network with no terms of use means that exploiting a flaw in someone else's code is not the same as deception. More than three years passed between the April 2023 exploit and the acquittal, and no conviction was ever entered.

Comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

or verify by email