Language
Quick access
Favorites
Info
Mobile Apps
Donwload on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
Follow us on social media
Kraken keeps trades after Bitcoin crashes to $17,000 in CAD pair
Markets

Kraken keeps trades after Bitcoin crashes to $17,000 in CAD pair

November 22, 20263 min read

Crypto exchange Kraken said it will not reverse trades that went through during a sharp crash on its Canadian-dollar markets. For a few minutes Bitcoin traded there at the equivalent of roughly $17,000, while other venues quoted about $57,000.

The exchange says there was no breach and every order was processed correctly. So why did the price drop by more than 70%? Here is what is known so far.

What exactly happened on Kraken's markets?

Heavy selling in the Canadian-dollar pairs began around 20:00 UTC on Friday. Prices there fell well below the rest of the market. The deepest point came in the 15-minute interval starting at 08:00 UTC on Saturday, when BTC/CAD dropped to C$24,250 per coin.

To compare, that figure has to be converted into US dollars. The Bank of Canada reference rate on Friday was C$1.4325 per US dollar, so the low works out to about $16,900. On Kraken's own BTC/USD market in the same five-minute window, Bitcoin traded near $57,650. The gap came to 71%.

Essence: for a brief moment Bitcoin in the BTC/CAD pair on Kraken cost 71% less than in BTC/USD, yet the exchange declared all trades valid.

How can Bitcoin cost a third as much on one market?

Kraken did not name a cause and only described the sequence of events. The one explanation came from Adam Back, CEO of Blockstream. In his view, a market maker on one of Kraken's Canadian-dollar spot markets may have run out of funds. A market maker is a firm that keeps posting buy and sell orders so the market has liquidity. The exchange has not confirmed this version.

Here is how that could work.

  • Buyers run out: every large sell order eats through buy orders, starting from the highest price and moving down the order book.
  • When a market maker with no funds stops posting its orders, the book is left with empty levels and the price falls to the nearest bid.
  • Normally arbitrageurs close such gaps by buying cheap on one market and selling higher on another.
  • According to Back, arbitrage then spread the distortion to other Canadian-dollar pairs.

This is only a hypothesis. There are no confirmed details yet.

Why did Kraken keep the trades in place?

In its statement the exchange wrote briefly: "Executed trades stand". It says orders were processed correctly and its security teams found no signs of a breach or compromised accounts. By that logic there is no reason for a rollback, since the system did what it was supposed to do.

The decision has a cost, though. Someone sold Bitcoin for next to nothing and locked in a loss, while someone else bought it at a discount nobody else saw. A reversal would change those outcomes after the fact, and that would be a contested move too. Cointelegraph asked Kraken for comment but had no reply by publication.

Incident numbers
BTC/CAD low on KrakenC$24,250
Bank of Canada rate (Friday)C$1.4325 per USD
Dollar equivalent~$16,900
BTC/USD on Kraken at the same time~$57,650
Gap~71%

How does this fit a market that is already shaking?

The incident landed in a week when Bitcoin was falling anyway. According to CoinDesk, on Friday it dropped below $57,000 for the first time in two years, and the wave of liquidations across crypto reached $1.8 billion. The price then bounced back above $60,000.

That does not explain why the Canadian pair in particular broke. It does remind us that on a nervous day a thin market snaps first.

How do you check a price when the market is rattled?

Our view is simple: a single pair on one exchange is not the market. Before a large trade, compare the price with at least two or three venues and avoid market orders on illiquid pairs. Prices on different crypto exchanges need not match every second, but a 71% gap is no normal margin of error.

If you want to exchange Bitcoin to dollars, it is easier to compare exchanger offers in one place. That is exactly why we collect rates at Kurslog.

Kraken has not yet explained the cause. Until it does, Back's version remains an assumption.

Comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

or verify by email